Bike when used at high intensity a stationary bike burns more calories than the elliptical making it a slightly better choice for those trying to lose weight.
Fan exercise bike vs elliptical.
While there are compact ellipticals they typically take up much more space than an exercise bike.
Burning fat as a goal there is a strong correlation between duration and intensity of exercise and the amount of fat burned during a workout.
According to the website healthstatus a 200 pound person will burn 477 calories during a moderate 45 minute workout on the exercise bike and 774 calories during a 45 minute workout on the.
Some may feel the elliptical motion is not natural and uncomfortable.
Some users report numb feet because the feet typically never leave the pedals.
An elliptical is that you are seated while exercising with your hands free for reading a book sending text messages or watching tv.
As a result of these differences using the elliptical burns about 30 more calories than using the recumbent bike and as a result is a more effective exercise machine for cardio and warm up exercises than the recumbent bike.
This can be rectified by periodically moving your feet around.
The elliptical however helps strengthen both your upper and lower body by engaging more muscle groups.